| 1888
Mabel Benson Lizzie Dalner Ora Evans Mary Ferguson Eva Kuhn Effie Lathrop Mary Lundy Will Miller Blanche Patton | 1889
Edna Lathrop Lulu Patton Lial Sutherland | 1890
Belle Briggs Ella Denton Jessie Eden Will Ferguson Jas. Fitzgerald Hattie Hall Nellie Hathaway Angie Kenyon Joseph Loch Ed Nickle Lovie Oard Clara Parker Cora Peters Chas. Smith Winifred Umphrey Harry Woolman | 1891
Gertrude Burnham Orrin Emmons Arthur Freelove John W. Jensen Charles Matteson Julia Moore Mamie O'Flyn Minnie Parker Albert Wood |
| 1892
Dora Atherton Mary Barnes Nica Burnham Chas. Emes Alma Franke Mamie Gardner John Ginther Azubah Hall Albert Henniger Lulu McCarty Jasper Signall | 1893
Anna Dau Viola Flaugh Albert Haley Bessie Hall Erwin Henniger Peter Jones Mary Kinney Hattie Leonard Joseph Nickum John Oard Jennie Peters Ida Pickett Chas. Redick Guy Ross Alta Shepherd Ralph Gordon Sutherland Effie Woolman | 1894
Effie Atherton Lila Blair Louella Cory Clara Emmons Edith Halford Belle E. Young | 1895
Mabel Daily Alva Franke Grace Funk Winnie Funk Laura Karstens Agnes Kinny Ivah Priest Rosa Radeleff Joe Ross |
| 1896
Edward Brent Ollie Freetly J.W. Miller Effie Parish Clint Russell Mary Sprinkle Robert Sutherland Ray Sutton | 1897
None | 1898
Agnes Blakeslee Grace Breckenridge Mollie Dethlefs Ida Hall Charles Koepke Jessie Wood | 1899
Charles Dickson Clarence Eden Olive Long |
| 1900
Effie Atherton Lillie Brent Henry Brunnier Lillian Halford C.O. Marshall Olive Millye B. Pickett Peter Rademan Nellie Signall Philip Signall Emma Summerville Robert Summerville Julius Tank Fred Wiseman | 1901
Jessie Atherton Myrtle Campbell Edna Godard Valentine Loch | 1902
John Campbell Ellis Frick Harry Hagedorn Ida Lenhart Carrie McDonald | 1903
Catherine Brunnier Mae Campbell Lola Franke John Lage Corda Long Otto Paysen Francis Peters Ryel Wheeler |
| 1904
George Albert Ellen Campbell Helen Franke Anna Gottsch Hans Hagedorn Anna Hansen Henry Hansen Rosa Kuhl Lulu Lienemann Mary Loch Will Motter Richard Schacht Emma Schoening Walter Weehlers Louella Wheeler Elsie Wilson | 1905
Lulu Bobar Frankie Campbell Lewis Finnerty Dorothy Franke Fred Hassler Laura Hoffman Ella Jones Maude McWilliams William Summerville | 1906
Harry Free Arthur Lafler John Rostermundt D.E. Sutherland Leland Wheeler | 1907
Floyd Campbell Kathryn Finnerty Gustave Franke Albert E. Moser Earl W. Rugg |
| 1908
Elizabeth Campbell Nina Free Ross Golden Ellen Hoesly Fred Hoesly Harry Motter Louis Ohm Harry Reinholdt John Reinhold Reginald Rorabaugh Augusta Schoening | 1909
Robert Campbell Clarence Frye Leman Gearhart Irene Harvey Mary Hayes Marie Moser Albert Puck Verna Schmidt | 1910
Edna Coomes Evelyn Grantz Ella Hansen Vida Gilberta Jensen Blanche Ridnour Karl Schmidt Lorene Thornton | 1911
Edgar Bobar Nettle Campbell Albert Dietz Florence Forbes Martha Gruhn Ida Motter Ella Ohde Gus Ohde Eulalia Rogers Ray Wiseman |
| 1912
Clara Grau Peter Hansen Margaret Hinrichs Orma Long Lola Moerke William Reinhold Robert Schoening Erna Schoening Thomas Torpy | 1913
Thomas Campbell Helen Dethlefs Mava Forbes Elsie Joens Julia Johnson Harry McMurray Dora Ohde Ola Parrott Carl Rohr Harry Wilson | 1914
Roy Barnes Don Branson Elsa Dethlefs Antonia Feldman Oscar Forbes Gertrude Grantz Ernest Gruhn Hilda Hansen Delphia Hays Ethel Lewis Bonito Lyden Melitta Moser Leo Navin Fay Pollock | 1915
Cecilia Addison Herbert Blair Sarah Campbell Hilda Dethlefs Irene Grantz Walter Grau Rose Hinz Hilda Ohde Minnie Potthast Clara Puck Ruth Rogers Alma Rohr Milda Schelldorf Geo. Weidner |
| 1916
Walter Aldrich Robert Dethlefs Ray Harvey Florence Horn Hulda Krumm Julia Mayer Ralph Parkhouse Rachel Roehse Opal Sweger | 1917
Winford Addison Bessie Dunnick Henry Grelck Edward Gronert Edna Halbur Blanche Hays Alva Hockett Roy Lawbaugh Velma Lewis Nola Long Ralph Moser Edna Motter John Ohde Martha Rohr Helen Ruge Lester Wiese | 1918
Jay Bingham Dean Curtis Catherine Dalgety Edwin Dethlefs Neal Dunnick Mabel Eaton Robert Emmons Edward Fredrickson Elsie Hinz Esther Johnson Marvin Meyers Esther Ohde Lillian Pfoltner Gerald Reimers Orlo Schelldorf Alta Wiese | 1919
Clifford Best John R. Hansen Francis Hickey Viola Horn Graydon Illsley Lillian Johnson Elma Mayer Raymond Motter Trella Ramsey Helen Rohr Victor Schultz Eula Sweger |